Sep 29, 2019 many scholars, often people of color and those from non western nations, pointed out over the years that modernization theory fails to account for the way western reliance on colonization, slave labor, and theft of land and resources provided the wealth and material resources necessary for the pace and scale of development in the west see postcolonial theory for extensive discussions of this. Download file to see previous pages the history of western alienation dates back to the forming of the dominion of canada and canada confederation in the year 1867. The concept of alienation belongs to a vast and complex problematics, with a long history of its own. Summary in spring 2019, alberta experienced the second change in government in just as many electionssomething that has never happened before in its history. Policymaking in canada has generally been controlled by eastern canada, even in matters concerning western provinces. Two main problems with this conceptualization of western alienation and, by extension, its claim about how we ought to understand alienation in western canada are identified and explained. Western alienation in canadian politics essay example. The differing status implied by the measure is even more painful in western canada than elsewhere because a disproportionate number of our residents, including ones of origin in asia, france, ukraine, germany, and our large aboriginal communities, have experienced what can occur when governments single out some communities as less than equal to. Roger gibbins, prairie politics and society wiley online library. The nep stabilized oil prices in central canada, but made it more expensive to drill oil, which hurt alberta.
Western alienation is a real problem but wexit should not. Rather, it aims to cleave away the entirety of western canada from eastern canada. Jun 01, 2010 the reform party and its later incarnation, the canadian alliance was a western based party that focused on themes including western alienation and seeking a voice for western interests in national politics. Search cbc digital archives search terms must be at least 3 characters in length. In canadian politics, western alienation is the notion that the western provinces british columbia, alberta, saskatchewan and manitoba have been alienated, and in extreme cases excluded, from mainstream canadian political affairs in favour of the central provinces of ontario and quebec. In alberta, the heartland of canadas energy industry, many feel they are being taken advantage of and. Shifting patterns of western canadian discontent with the federal government loleen berdahl, ph.
Im still pretty new to canadian politics and i am taking a course about it right now actually. As is well known, feuerbach, hegel and english political economy exercised the most direct influence on the formation of marxs theory of alienation. Many scholars, often people of color and those from nonwestern nations, pointed out over the years that modernization theory fails to account for the way western reliance on colonization, slave labor, and theft of land and resources provided the wealth and material resources necessary for the pace and scale of development in the west see postcolonial theory for extensive discussions of this. From lurking sentiments of the underrepresentation of western regions in federal politics to overt statements proclaiming let the eastern bastards freeze in the dark, western alienation has persisted throughout the history of confederation. In this paper, i adopt an intellectual history approach which creates. Nonetheless, wexit is not just an albertan movement. You will find out how the different groups of people living there felt about becoming part of canada and the changes that were happening. Research fellow october 2010 canada is stronger when the west is thriving. The alternative vision of western canadians collided with official ottawa on numerous economic, political and cultural issues. Micheal woods 20 july 2009 recent data from the department of child protection in wester. Mar 07, 2018 this entry is one of three survey entries on the economic history of canada.
For more on this period of western canadian history, see smiley. Macdonald implemented a national policy with regard to manufactured goods and trade policies. Western alienation is real but anger needs to be channelled. In the 1980s, in the wake of the national energy program and a severe recession, the western canada concept party was born and managed to elect an mla. Government, federalism, and politics unit iiigovernment, federalism, and politics page references unit iii topics and focusing questions 1. Jun 27, 2014 how ottawas first world war plans sparked western alienation. Canada, it is rising in ontario and holding steady in atlantic canada while western canadians were the most likely to report discontent in 2004, by 2008 it was atlantic canadians who registered the highest levels of discontent. When it comes to anger in the west, history keeps repeating itself it feels like western alienation is at an alltime high, but anywhere you look at. Alienation is part of the identity of western canada, says author mary janigan, and traces back over a century when the western provinces were created and control of their resources was given to. Canada is a constitutional monarchy, a parliamentary democracy, and a federal state. Despite justified feelings of western alienation, wexit would bring mutually assured destruction to all canadians.
The reform party and its later incarnation, the canadian alliance was a westernbased party that focused on themes including western alienation and seeking a voice for western interests in national politics. In aboriginal people and colonizers of western canada to 1900, sarah carter looks at the cultural, political, and economic issues of this contested history, focusing on the western interior, or what would later become canadas prairie provinces. Western alienation picked up strength with trudeau sr. Canada faces western alienation in energy heartland alberta. Relying upon survey data collected in the 1997 canadian election study ces, this study attempts to substantively quantify western regional alienation and identify its correlates. It feels like western alienation is at an alltime high, but anywhere you look at any point in our history you see and feel incarnations of alienation. The declaration then delves into a history of the province, suggesting the. The socialist labor party, an offshoot of the slp of the united states, appeared in the. History senior high 1 alberta education, alberta, canada revised 1985 western canadian history 20 objectives the objectives of western canadian history 20 are.
In canadian politics, western alienation is the notion that the western provinces british. Looking at western alienation from different angles. Originally published by canada history company, toronto, 1906 this edition by global heritage press, milton, 2003 cd 2011 bryces comprehensive history of manitoba is invaluable for those who are interested in the history of early manitoba in general, and the families and individuals who settled in the region before 1906 in particular. Western visions, western futures perspectives on the west in. Aug 09, 2019 alienation is part of the identity of western canada, says author mary janigan, and traces back over a century when the western provinces were created and control of their resources was given to. Western anger at ottawa is growing, the angus reid institute finds in its latest poll on the west s place in canada, presenting a challenge for all mainstream parties including the conservatives in this election year. Western visions, western futures perspectives on the west. Many governments were notorious for percieved western alienation, particularly pierre trudeau with his national energy policy. Your browser doesnt seem to have a pdf viewer, please download the. For residents of canadas texas, a sense of western alienation. Western alienation is a real problem but wexit should. Because political alienation is rooted in discontent with political representatives, institutions, and procedures for decisionmaking associated with representative government in canada, the essay concludes that the curative benefits attributed to regionally biased institutional reform of the federal government e.
To many in the west, ottawa is viewed as preoccupied with the quebec ontario axis and makes most of its decisions based upon how they will effect central canada. This is due to first, eastern canada being more populous historically, much more so and being host to the centers of economy torontomontreal and politics ottawa. I know western canada is upset with the east listen, you had a heritage fund, it could have been cool, paid for a rainy day, but you blew it but is western separatism really as popular as mister manning is crying. Jobkilling carbon tax is a way for the conservatives to tie themselves to one side of that western history and new democrats to the other.
The essay argues that the problem of political alienation is central to understanding the alienation of many citizens in western canada. Channelled incorrectly, western alienation is unproductive and just comes across as juvenile whining that alberta isnt getting its way. Apr 29, 2016 the 1980 national energy program nep was an attempt by the federal government to gain greater control over the canadian petroleum industry, secure canadian oil supplies, and redistribute albertas oil wealth to the rest of the country. Project muse understanding alienation in western canada. Pdf fiscal equalization is a key political issue in many federal countries, including. Preoccupations with this problematics in forms ranging from the bible to literary works as well as treatises on law, economy and philosophy reflect objective trends of european development, from. But we are concerned here with much more than simple intellectual influences. By derek baker, december 19 2018 albertas federal relations have never been overly congenial. Western alienation definition and meaning collins english.
Second, western canadians feel that the canadian political system operates in favour. Energy east and the rebirth of western alienation ipolitics. While western regional alienation has been the subject of much scholarly and public debate in canada, we still know relatively little about the factors driving the phenomenon. A splinter group formed the western independence party in 1987. Western alienation claims that these latter two are politically represented, and economically favoured, more significantly than the former, which has given rise to the sentiment of alienation among. Canadas government created yukon territory to meet the needs of the areas growing population.
Dec 19, 2018 western alienation is a real and powerful political tool to rally support, but it also contributes to the current divisiveness of federal politics. Western alienation is a term used in canadian politics to describe the four. See also economic history of atlantic canada and economic history of central canada. Library of parliament, research branch, 1984 canada 17 pages. This entry is one of three survey entries on the economic history of canada. Jul 02, 2018 while many of us will be celebrating canada day this weekend, outburst contributor jen gerson heard from some albertans who feel alienated by the rest of canada and still harbour thoughts of. Introduction discussions of western canada often make reference to the sentiment of regional discontent with the federal government, more commonly referred to as western alienation. For almost as long as canada has been a country, the western provinces have been fighting the centre for control of their natural goods. To support an opinion orally, to understand federalprovincial political tensions.
Discover canada the rights and responsibilities of citizenship. Alberta mps issue buffalo declaration to call on ottawa to. High tariffs from 1878 until recently in some items, discriminatory freight rates that encouraged manufacturing in central canada and commodity extraction in the west. Montreal the concept of western alienation is real and dangerous, and people in the region feel as though their aspirations arent in line with those in the rest of canada, rona ambrose said. Students will research, discuss, and support arguments about western canadian alienation from the rest of canada. Because of the paucity of research on divorce in canada, ambert is often forced. Gold was discovered along the western coast of canada in 1896 1898. Asserting our citizenship to manitoba social studies senior 3 curriculum. But then again has canadian federalism really been tested. Parental alienation involves the systematic brainwashing, poisoning and manipulation of children with the sole purpose of destroying a loving and warm relationship they once shared with a parent.
Quebec nationalism, western alienation, and national. Resources western canada history and genealogy books. And the legacy of western alienation is this deep and abiding suspicion of the federal government. Taking an historical and institutionalist perspective, this article explores the politics. Western canada is the traditional territory of numerous first nations predating the arrival of europeans. Proponents of the western alienation may suggest that complaints in western canada most often have to do with matters falling within the jurisdiction of the federal government, such as trade policy, tariffs, equalization procedures, and various aspects of fiscal arrangements pertaining to federal social program investment and expenditure. A group calling for western canada to separate from the rest of the. Western alienation videos and latest news articles. Pdf western alienation or mere critique of federal government. Its not uncommon for canadian parties to only win seats in one region. Economic history of western canada the canadian encyclopedia.
As britain colonized the west, it established treaties with various first nations, took control of other areas without opposition and fought with other first nations to take control of western canada. Western alienation has had its roots causes in the western canada s disappointment at not having more control over the federal government. While many of us will be celebrating canada day this weekend, outburst contributor jen gerson heard from some albertans who feel alienated by. In class the concept of western alienation was briefly mentioned and my question is, where does this come from. Contents key findings introduction provincial differences in western canadian attitudes toward the federal government. Because political alienation is rooted in discontent with political representatives, institutions, and procedures for decisionmaking associated with representative government in canada, the essay concludes. Social democracy and western alienation in saskatchewan politics. The history of canadas aboriginal peoples after european contact is a hotly debated area of study. Economic development in what is now western canada began with the fur trade.
Roger gibbins, a senior fellow at the canada west foundation, and an. You will study how western canada changed and developed between 1867 and 1890. Quebec nationalism, western alienation, and national reconciliation paper by david kilgour, m. It has its roots deep in the regions history, particularly on the prairies, which entered confederation on a different basis from the other provinces. Japanese internment camps were established during world war ii by president franklin roosevelt through his executive order 9066. So the powerful feelings of alienation in the west need to be acknowledged. Dec 06, 2019 nonetheless, wexit is not just an albertan movement.
696 925 906 744 924 1211 118 481 49 1005 347 904 18 753 837 109 946 1561 98 749 343 28 842 731 1263 259 732 1298 1330 301 1111